Of course the whole game is about questions and answers and it is normal for someone to have a stab at the first part of the answer and if he's right he can then go off and look for the remaining answers armed with some knowledge.
I think fromwien would probably have locked it for max had he seen his answer before you posted yours, to give him the chance to post the rest of the answers, but he hadn't so you were of course entitled to answer in full and I think in this instance he was correct to give a point to both max and you, Alfa.
That way we should have two happy puzzlers!